Exploring Umbrella Insurance: Safeguarding Your Rental Property Investment

exploring umbrella insurance: safeguarding your rental property investment

Standard insurance policies might not cover everything you need to protect your rental properties. That’s where rental property umbrella insurance comes in—it’s like an extra layer of security for property owners.

This blog explains umbrella insurance rental property coverage, how it works, and how it compares to a standard landlord insurance policy.

What is an Umbrella Policy for Rental Property?

An umbrella policy for rental property provides additional coverage when an existing policy reaches its limit. This includes additional business and personal liability protection and personal injury coverage. It’s especially helpful for landlords with multiple properties or rentals in areas with higher risks.

For instance, if a tenant gets injured on your property and the medical expenses exceed what your primary insurance policy covers. Umbrella insurance for rental properties covers the extra costs and protects against personal injury claims or lawsuits that surpass typical insurance coverage.

How Does Umbrella Insurance for Rental Property Work?

Let’s say your rental property insurance has a liability limit of $300,000, but you have to pay $500,000 in damages for a personal injury claim. In that case, an umbrella policy can cover the remaining $200,000 (assuming this amount is included in your umbrella coverage).

Leasing a rental property without umbrella insurance would make you responsible for any leftover amount that standard types of insurance don’t cover. Plus, legal claims and expenses can threaten your rental property investment and personal assets.

Basically, landlord umbrella insurance gives you peace of mind in the unpredictable world of renting properties, shielding you from unforeseen liabilities.

Landlord Umbrella Insurance Coverage Includes:

  • Bodily Injury: The policy offers extra protection if a tenant or their guest gets hurt because of poor property maintenance, like getting a shock from a faulty electrical system.
  • Third-Party Damages: If, for instance, a neighbor sues for damages caused by your tenant, the umbrella policy addresses these liability risks.
  • Theft or Damage: Covers situations like when a former tenant breaks in and damages or steals the current tenant’s property due to unchanged locks.
  • Trespasser Injuries: If a squatter gets injured on a vacant property and sues, the policy will help.
  • Common Area Injuries: In multifamily properties, if someone gets injured in shared spaces like the laundry room, the policy provides a level of coverage against lawsuits.
  • Legal Expenses: The policy can cover the associated legal expenses even if the landlord isn’t at fault but gets sued.

An umbrella policy covers multiple investment properties under one shield, so landlords have consistent protection from unexpected events.

Landlord Umbrella Insurance Coverage Excludes:

  • Property Damage: An umbrella policy only includes extra protection primarily for liability, not for damage to the property itself. Property damage is generally covered by a standard landlord policy.
  • Intentional Damage: Damage intentionally caused by the landlord or a related party isn’t covered. For instance, if a landlord is sued for illegal eviction, the umbrella policy won’t kick in.
  • Personal Injuries: Any bodily injury or expenses sustained by the landlord aren’t covered by rental property umbrella insurance.
  • Punitive Damages: Payment owed on top of compensatory damages for an injury or are generally not included in umbrella coverage.
  • Business Activities: A personal umbrella insurance policy might not offer coverage if a rental property operates under an LLC. Instead, a rental business or commercial umbrella policy would be required.

It’s important to understand the level of risk you’re exposed to and work closely with an insurance professional to ensure comprehensive protection across all fronts.

How Much Umbrella Insurance Do I Need for a Rental Property?

Rental property umbrella insurance costs depend on multiple variables, such as the property type and value, location, claim history, and deductible. Liability limits will also vary for different types of real estate investors but generally range from $1-$25 million. Many carriers provide coverage in $1 million increments for $150 to $350 per year per Kiplinger

Here’s a simple guide to help decide the right amount of umbrella coverage:

  • Property Value: Consider the value of each rental property. If it’s worth $300,000, you’ll want coverage that matches this amount.
  • Personal Property: Calculate the value of personal assets, like savings, cars, or other properties. The more assets you have, the higher coverage you need to protect them.
  • Potential Risks: Some areas have a higher risk level for break-ins or theft, which requires additional coverage.
  • Existing Coverage: Check primary insurance policy limits. If the liability coverage limit is $500,000, but your risk level requires $1 million, you’d want an umbrella policy to cover the $500,000 gap.

Consult with an insurance professional or insurance company for advice on the best umbrella policy rental property coverage. Request an estimate to compare coverage and premiums.

Umbrella Insurance vs. Rental Property Insurance

Generally, there are two types of insurance for rental properties: landlord insurance and umbrella insurance for landlords.

Landlord Insurance

This insurance covers damages to your rental property, loss of rental income due to these damages, and legal fees from potential tenant lawsuits.


  • Protects financial security
  • Coverage for property damage
  • Includes rent guarantee insurance


  • Standard policy limits for liability claims
  • More financial risks for costly lawsuits

Landlord insurance can be useful if you only need basic coverage for a single property with a handful of tenants.

Umbrella Insurance

This rental property insurance is an extension of standard insurance policies for landlords to provide extra liability coverage for certain property damage claims, personal injuries, and legal costs.


  • Comprehensive landlord insurance
  • Additional liability coverage
  • Extra financial protection for legal costs


  • Additional costs on top of landlord insurance
  • Excludes property damage coverage

An umbrella insurance policy is ideal if you own multiple rental properties, especially larger complexes. Consider adding umbrella insurance to standard types of landlord insurance for comprehensive coverage.

Final Thoughts

An umbrella policy steps in when standard landlord insurance policies exceed coverage limits, offering peace of mind knowing financial assistance for unexpected events is there when you need it.

Get an instant quote for Baselane landlord insurance that can save up to 25% on your existing policy.

In this article:
Get the Right Coverage for your Rental

Trusted by 30,000+ landlords and investors

  • Check if you can save $100’s on existing policy
  • Make sure you have the right coverage
  • No phone call or hassle required
Avatar photo
Financial Technology, Real Estate Investing, and Property Management, Accounting and Tax, Finance
Saad started his career as a Certified Public Accountant (CPA) working for a top-tier accounting firm. He was responsible for helping audit alternative investment funds. He later worked at a hedge fund where he was responsible for preparing financial statements and implementing new technology. He also ran a successful private tax practice for five years.

After completing his MBA at Duke, Saad joined The Boston Consulting Group to do management consulting. At BCG his experience spanned several industries and growth projects across Pharma, Retail, and Technology companies. His passion for democratizing finances led him to Plaid, a fintech, where he worked with large Banks and Financial Institutions to make finances and money easier for all.
Share this article:
exploring umbrella insurance: safeguarding your rental property investment
Exploring Umbrella Insurance: Safeguarding Your Rental Property Investment

Save on Property Insurance

Get an Instant Quote

Get an Instant Insurance Quote

Property Insurance Estimate

Click here to insure your property

Powered by Obie